Cripple. History Major. Vaguely Left-Wing.

Alt of PugJesus for ensuring Fediverse compatibility and shit

  • 474 Posts
  • 445 Comments
Joined 11 months ago
cake
Cake day: July 21st, 2023

help-circle






  • Death sentence does not, and has never, worked as a deterrent.

    The death penalty doesn’t work on irrational actors - ie the desperate and the mentally unwell. Those who commit most crimes. The death penalty as a deterrent to rational actors (such as opportunistic politicians) is very much part of the mental calculus that goes into decision-making.

    It’s also super fucked to say “sometimes you gotta kill a guy cause too many people agree with him.”

    No, that’s actually pretty normal. People agreeing with genocidal dictators is a bad thing, and taking out the dictator is greatly preferable to taking out all the people who agree.




  • Espionage outside of wartime is still done through the civilian courts, and treason trials (such as for an ousted genocidal dictator) would likely be done through civilian courts as well.

    But yes, they’re generally more military/extreme edge cases that I feel the death penalty is warranted in. Murder? Theft? Taking up two parking spaces? Prison is good enough.

    US States have no purpose applying capital punishment beyond revenge.

    That I agree with.




    1. The death penalty is an important bargaining tool with the spies of other countries in regards to serious cases of espionage.

    2. It may be necessary to apply the death penalty in the case of a state in dire circumstances in which the release or escape of a prisoner may be regarded as deadly to the commonwealth - such as a dictator with large minority support or support amongst the elite still remaining being prosecuted for their crimes.

    3. As deterrent in extreme matters of desertion, war crimes, or crimes against peace.

    Fucking wild that a place where the sentiment of ‘eat the rich’ is commonly passed around recoils at the idea of executing a dictator after a trial if his crimes warrant it and there’s a reasonable threat that he could be sprung and returned to power by the elite or a radical minority.

    Like, really?